Canadian Pacific Stock Analysis – Buyback Focus

Canadian Pacific stock analysis content:

  • CP stock price analysis
  • CP business overview
  • CP financials and fundamentals
  • CP dividend and buybacks
  • CP stock valuation
  • CP comparative analysis and investment thesis

Canadian Pacific Stock – TSE: CP, NYSE: CP

This Canadian National Railway stock analysis is part of my full railroad stocks sector analysis. Here is the:

If you prefer enjoying a coffee and listening to the content, here is the video on rail stocks, CP stock article continues below.

Railroad stocks video analysis

Canadian Pacific stock price overview

Like it has been the case for other railroad stocks, the application of precision railroading has improved margins while lower general interest rates increased the attractiveness of the created cash flows where good economic growth added to the mix. Consequently, Canadian Pacific stock is another railroad stock that has been a ten bagger over the last 10 years.

Canadian Pacific stock price chart
Canadian Pacific stock price chart

The market capitalization is $40 billion. To be used in valuations later.

We see how CP stock has quickly recovered from the current crisis and we have to see how sensible it is to invest into it now compared to other railroad stocks.

CP business overview

Unlike CSX (CSX stock analysis) that has railroads in highly populated and dense areas in the Eastern part of the U.S., CP has railroads in unpopulated areas.

CP railroads – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
CP railroads – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

CP’s revenues are well diversified and there is not a big exposure to one specific segment. 40% of revenues come from bulk. As commodities have been in a slump over the last decade, a boom in such commodities might give a boost to CP.

.

CP railroads revenue mix – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

Given that growth in the railroad business depends mostly on the economic situation and demand for transport, companies try to find other options to grow. CP’s focus is to develop its available land as a primary growth focus because other options mostly depend on demand.

CP railroads growth plans – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

Of course, the return on such investments will depend on traffic and economic activity, but it is good to do if the return on capital invested is high alongside other operational improvements.

CP railroads land opportunity – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
CP railroads land opportunity – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

All in all, CP is a stable railway business, class-1 and will like be in business for a long time. Let’s take a look at the fundamentals.

CP stock analysis – fundamentals and finances

Over the last years, CP has achieved slow but steady growth in revenues and operating earnings. Improved operating ratios allowed for significant net income growth while buybacks pushed earnings per share from $8.4 in 2015 to $16.44 in 2019.

Canadian Pacific stock financials – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
Canadian Pacific stock financials – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

However, free cash flows have remained stable at $1.3 billion as the company is constantly investing. Average capital expenditures are around $1.6 billion.

Canadian Pacific capital expenditures - Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
Canadian Pacific capital expenditures – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

With returns on invested capital constantly in the teens, it shouldn’t be a bad factor to invest so much.

Debt to assets is in line with other railroad stocks but has been increasing over the years.

Canadian Pacific debt to assets – Source: Author’s calculations
Canadian Pacific debt to assets – Source: Author’s calculations

Interest coverage has increased but depends on the economic situation where the last years have been really good and interest rates have been declining. In case there is less economic activity and interest rates increase, debt ratios might not look that good anymore and increase at a much faster rate.

Canadian Pacific stock – interest cover – Source: Author’s calculations
Canadian Pacific stock – interest cover – Source: Author’s calculations

Total long-term debt is $7 billion and has increased from $4 billion in 2010. Most of the debt is in US$ ($6 billion) and the interest rate is relatively high. The 100-year USD note issued in 2015 has an interest rate of 6.125%.

Canadian Pacific debt structure – Source: CP annual report 2019
Canadian Pacific debt structure – Source: CP annual report 2019

The CAD$8.2 billion maturities should be manageable despite the currency risk there.

Canadian Pacific dividend and buybacks

The company has been paying approximately $300 million per year in dividends while buyback spending depends on the year. They spent $1.7 billion in 2014, $2 billion in 2015 and $885 million over the last twelve months.

Canadian Pacific dividend and buybacks – Source: SA
Canadian Pacific dividend and buybacks – Source: SA

Their strategy is to constantly increase the dividend and also do as much buybacks as they can.

Canadian Pacific capital expenditures - Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
Canadian Pacific capital expenditures – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

In general, apart from the large above average spending in 2014 and 2015 on buybacks, they are spending their available free cash flow partly for dividends and mostly for buybacks. The free cash flow is what I am going to use in valuation because I don’t like it when a company takes on debt to do buybacks. They spent $2.7 billion on buybacks in 2015 but also issued a $1.16 billion 100 year not with an interest rate of 6.125%. That debt and interest payment is going to be there up till 2115 while the buyback yield might not be above 6.125%.

Canadian Pacific stock valuation

With free cash flows of $1.3 billion on a $41 billion market capitalization the free cash flow yield is just 3.1%. Of course, there could be some growth coming their way from an improved economic situation in North America or higher commodity prices but I would say their growth will be in line with the growth of the whole rail sector.

A free cash flow yield of 3.1% is really low but given the position the company has, the fact that you can’t avoid it when doing business, especially with the needed commodities where its revenue fell only 9% in Q2 2020 compared to CSX’s total revenue decline of 26%, is a clear indication of strength. So, the question is how does such a good business fit your portfolio at current prices?

Canadian Pacific stock comparison

Canadian Pacific’s focus is to reward shareholders through buybacks.

Canadian Pacific capital expenditures - Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations
Canadian Pacific capital expenditures – Source: Canadian Pacific Investor Relations

Doing buybacks pushes the stock price higher and higher and one can argue weather that is good and for whom it is good. It is good for those selling the stock at higher prices but actually not good for long-term investors because the yield on their reinvestment is lower and lower as the stock price goes higher. Plus, the debt burden is going to be there for the long-term. Doing buybacks at any cost is a game that will backfire at some point in time. But, as all the other railroads are doing it, you would be the only stupid one not doing it.

Railroad stocks analysis – Compiled by author
Railroad stocks analysis – Compiled by author

Actually, the only railroad that has no debt and isn’t doing any crazy buybacks to push its stock higher is Burlington, owned by Berkshire. It is interesting how all other railroad stocks have similar metrics so Burlington stands out. In the short term, given the management’s focus on buybacks, all railroad stocks might go higher, but in the long-term, be ready to see Burlington take them over at bargain prices when the current positive environment changes, it always does.

If you are an investor in Canadian Pacific, think about your strategy, will it be to sell when the stock price goes higher thanks to buybacks because holding for the dividend isn’t smart anymore because it isn’t the management’s focus. The buyback game is made for the stock to be sold at some point in time. Unfortunately, nobody knows when the buyback game ends.

For more information on other railways stocks, please check my comparative railway stocks article with links to detailed analyses such as this one. Also, if you enjoy such a comprehensive sector analysis approach, please consider subscribing.

From a fundamental perspective, the best railroad stock to buy on the market is Burlington through Berkshire.

If you like this comprehensive approach to investing, please subscribe to my newsletter to be notified when I analyse a new sector. To check my past analyses, covered stocks and portfolios, feel free to check my Stock Market Research Platform.

Receive a weekly overview of published articles, videos and research reports straight to your inbox for boring long-term investing knowledge!

FREE VALUE Investing Course

Sign up for the FREE Value Investing course and get a comprehensive look into how I research businesses, over 7000 students have enrolled so far!

×